Manuscript formatting for journal submission: the checklist
Manuscript formatting for a journal means following the target journal's author guidelines. Common requirements are a Word file (or a PDF built from LaTeX), double-spaced text in one column, page numbers and continuous line numbers, a title page, an abstract and keywords, tables in the text, figures as separate files and references in the journal's style. The journal's own guidelines always win over any general checklist, including this one.
- Open the journal's author guidelines (often called "Guide for Authors" or "Instructions for Authors") and download its template if it has one.
- Set double spacing (Design › Paragraph Spacing › Double), page numbers (Insert › Page Number) and continuous line numbers (Layout › Line Numbers › Continuous).
- Put the parts in the journal's order: title page, abstract and keywords, main text, acknowledgements, references, then captions and tables where the journal wants them.
- Prepare figures as separate files if the journal asks, and format the references in its style.
- For double-anonymous review, save a second copy without names, then remove hidden personal data with File › Info › Check for Issues › Inspect Document (Word for Windows).
01Start with the journal's author guidelines
The author guidelines are the journal's own rules for a submitted manuscript: file type, length, structure, reference style, figure files and the statements it needs. There is no single journal format. Even the ICMJE Recommendations, which many medical journals follow, leave the details to each journal: abstracts go "in the format specified by the journal", tables follow "the specific journal's requirements", and the word count shows whether a manuscript "fits within the journal's formats and word limits". Every rule below is a common default, not a universal one.
Before you change a single setting, find these points in the guidelines and write them down:
- Article type and length: the word limit, what it counts, and the limits on tables, figures and references.
- File: Word, LaTeX or PDF, and whether there is a template to download.
- Layout: spacing, line numbers, page numbers, heading levels, footnotes allowed or not.
- Structure: the order of the parts, and whether the abstract is structured (with headings) or a single paragraph.
- Tables and figures: in the text, at the end, or as separate files.
- References: the style (APA, Vancouver, Harvard, IEEE and so on).
- Review model: whether peer review is double-anonymous, which means a second, anonymised file.
Reading the guidelines well is a skill of its own; my guide on how to read and apply journal author guidelines walks through one page of them line by line.
Format-free submission: do you need to format at all?
A format-free submission is a first submission that the journal accepts in any reasonable layout, with the formatting done only after acceptance. Elsevier's "Your Paper, Your Way" option works like this: references need all the necessary information but no specific style, and the paper must still contain the key elements (title, abstract, introduction, methods, results and discussion, references, figures and legends) and mandatory statements such as the conflict of interest declaration. Taylor & Francis says many of its journals allow format-free submission, as long as the citation format is consistent. Whether a given journal offers it is written in its own guidelines.
Other journals check the format at the door. PLOS ONE, for example, sets the file type, spacing, line numbering and figure files for the first submission. Table 1 compares what these sources ask for.
| Point | ICMJE | PLOS ONE | Elsevier (format-free) | T&F (format-free) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Layout | The journal's own format | Double spaced, one column, page and continuous line numbers | Any, at first submission | Any, where the journal allows it |
| File | Not set | DOC, DOCX or RTF; LaTeX as PDF | Most journals accept a PDF from LaTeX | Check the journal |
| References | Numbered in order of first citation (NLM style) | Vancouver, as [1] | Any style, if complete | Any consistent style |
| Figures | Legends on a separate page | Separate files; captions in the text | Figures and legends included | Check the journal |
Note. Summarised from each publisher's own pages, listed under Sources. Individual journals can add to or change these rules.
Even when the first submission is format-free, I set double spacing, line numbers and page numbers from the start. Reviewers comment by page and line, and a manuscript that is already close to the journal's format needs a far shorter fix after acceptance.
02Standard manuscript format: the settings
The standard manuscript format for an academic journal is a plain review copy: double-spaced text in a single column, a standard font, page numbers on every page and line numbers running continuously through the file. PLOS ONE's guidelines set exactly these rules, and many journals that ask for a fixed layout ask for something close. The typeset look of the published article comes later, from the journal.
The settings, with the source for each rule:
- Spacing: double spaced, single column (PLOS ONE). Some journals accept 1.5; check yours.
- Font: PLOS ONE accepts any standard font at a standard size, but not the font called Symbol; insert symbols with Insert › Symbol instead. Where a journal names a font, use that one.
- Page numbers: on every page (PLOS ONE).
- Line numbers: continuous through the whole file, not restarting on each page (PLOS ONE).
- Headings: no more than three levels in PLOS ONE, clearly distinguished.
- Footnotes: not permitted in PLOS ONE; move the content into the text or the references. Other journals allow them.
- Abbreviations: spelled out at first use, with the abbreviation in parentheses, and kept out of the title (ICMJE).
- File: Word files "should not be locked or protected" (PLOS ONE).
Manuscript format example
Figure 2 shows what a page of a manuscript in this format looks like.
Margins and font size are rarely fixed by journals that publish in their own typeset layout, but some do set them. When they do, the rule is in the guidelines or built into the template; a template's styles already carry the right settings, so apply them rather than formatting by hand.
For an APA journal, the manuscript follows APA's professional paper format instead, with a running head and an author note; that is covered in APA professional manuscript format. IEEE journals and conferences work from IEEE's own templates, explained in the IEEE paper format guide.
03Set up the manuscript in Word or Google Docs
Setting up a journal manuscript in Word takes three settings: double spacing from Design › Paragraph Spacing, page numbers from Insert › Page Number, and line numbers from Layout › Line Numbers. Microsoft Support gives the same paths for Word for Microsoft 365. Set them once on the whole file, before you paste in tables and figures.
Double spacing
- To double-space the whole document, choose Design › Paragraph Spacing and click Double.
- To double-space only some paragraphs, select them and choose Home › Line and Paragraph Spacing, then 2.0.
If parts of the file stay single spaced, they use a different style or carry direct formatting from pasting. My guide to double spacing in Word covers those cases and exact spacing values.
Page numbers
- WindowsChoose Insert › Page Number and pick the position and style.
- MacChoose Insert › Page Number, then Page Number, select a position and an alignment, and click OK.
Line numbers
- If the manuscript has section breaks, select the whole document first: Ctrl+A on Windows, Cmd+A on a Mac.
- Choose Layout › Line Numbers.
- Click Continuous. For a step other than 1 (every fifth line, say), choose Line Numbering Options, click Line Numbers, tick Add line numbering and set the interval there.
- Check the result in Print Layout view (View › Print Layout). Line numbers don't show in the other views.
By default Word skips lines in tables, footnotes, endnotes, text boxes, headers and footers (Microsoft Support, Add or remove line numbers). A table or figure counts as one line. That is normal, and journals expect it.
In Google Docs
WebGoogle Docs has line numbers too, but only in pages format, not pageless. Choose Tools › Line numbers and tick Show line numbers; the numbers run through the whole document by default. Page numbers are under Insert › Page elements › Page number. Most journals want a Word file, so finish with File › Download and choose Microsoft Word (.docx), then open the result in Word and check the line numbers, the tables and the page numbers before you upload it.
A full walk-through of the line-number options, including suppressing them on the title page, is in adding line numbers in Word.
04Journal article format: parts and order
The usual journal article format for original research is IMRaD: Introduction, Methods, Results and Discussion, preceded by a title page and an abstract and followed by acknowledgements and references. The ICMJE Recommendations describe IMRaD as the usual structure for original research, while reviews, case reports and editorials may be less structured. The exact order of the parts, and where tables and figure captions go, comes from the journal.
PLOS ONE's order is a good example of a fixed one:
- Title page: title, authors and affiliations, as the first page of the file.
- Abstract (up to 300 words in PLOS ONE, no citations), then the Introduction.
- Materials and Methods, Results, Discussion and an optional Conclusions section, which PLOS ONE lets you rename and reorder.
- Acknowledgements, References and supporting information captions, in that order.
In PLOS ONE, each table and each figure caption goes in the text straight after the paragraph that first cites it, and the figure images are uploaded separately. ICMJE describes the other common pattern: figure legends together on a separate page.
What goes on the title page
The ICMJE Recommendations list the title page contents: the article title, the authors' names and affiliations, contact details for the corresponding author (with email), disclaimers, sources of support, a word count of the text, the number of tables and figures if the submission system asks, and each author's disclosures. Some journals also want a short title, usually no more than 40 characters including letters and spaces (ICMJE); PLOS ONE allows a short title of up to 100 characters. Frontiers likewise asks for the word count and the number of figures and tables on the first page. The details are in the manuscript title page guide.
Word count
The ICMJE word count covers the text only, excluding the abstract, acknowledgements, tables, figure legends and references. Frontiers counts the main text, footnotes and in-text citations. Journals differ, so read which parts yours counts. In Word, select the text you need to count: the status bar shows the count for the selection and for the whole document.
How each IMRaD section is built, with examples, is in journal article structure; review articles follow a different plan, covered in review paper format.
05Tables and figures
Tables and figures in a journal manuscript are numbered in the order they are first cited in the text, and every one must be cited (ICMJE). Tables usually stay in the manuscript file; figures often go as separate image files, with their captions or legends in the manuscript. ICMJE also wants each table to have a short, self-explanatory title and explanations in footnotes, and titles and explanations of figures in the legends, not on the images.
Tables
- Number tables consecutively and give each a short title (ICMJE). PLOS ONE puts the label ("Table 1") and title above the table, and notes and footnotes below.
- Keep column headings short; explain non-standard abbreviations in footnotes and name the measure of variation, such as standard deviation (ICMJE).
- Build tables with Word's table feature, not tabs or spaces, and never paste a table as a picture. Elsevier's artwork checklist names Excel for charts and tables. My own rule: if a reviewer can't select a number in it, it isn't a table.
Figures
- PLOS ONE: don't put figures in the manuscript file; upload each as its own file, named to match its citation (Fig 1 is
Fig1.tif). The caption, with a label such as "Fig 1" and a short title, goes in the text after the paragraph that first cites the figure. - Elsevier's artwork checklist lists TIFF or JPEG for halftones (photographs), EPS or PDF for vector graphics, and Office files for charts and annotated images, in RGB unless the journal says otherwise.
- ICMJE: letters and symbols must stay legible when the figure is reduced, and previously published figures need written permission from the copyright holder.
- Elsevier: "no specific feature within an image may be enhanced, obscured, moved, removed or introduced".
Resolution rules (dots per inch) differ by journal and publisher, so take the figures you need from the journal's own artwork page.
Submitting to a journal?I format your manuscript to the author guidelines
06References and citation style
The reference style of a journal manuscript is set by the journal: APA, Harvard, Vancouver, IEEE, Chicago or the journal's house style. ICMJE asks for references numbered consecutively in the order they are first cited, shown as Arabic numerals in parentheses, in the NLM style of Citing Medicine. PLOS ONE also uses Vancouver style but puts the numbers in square brackets, [1], so even two numbered styles can differ. Format-free routes at Elsevier and Taylor & Francis accept any style at first submission, as long as it is complete and consistent.
The same reference in two styles shows how much changes:
- APA 7: Morgan, R. M., & Hunt, S. D. (1994). The commitment-trust theory of relationship marketing. Journal of Marketing, 58(3), 20–38. https://doi.org/10.1177/002224299405800302
- Vancouver: 1. Morgan RM, Hunt SD. The commitment-trust theory of relationship marketing. J Mark. 1994;58(3):20-38.
Change the style in your reference manager (Zotero, Mendeley or EndNote) rather than editing references by hand: the citations in the text change with it, from (Morgan & Hunt, 1994) to (1) or [1], depending on the journal. Setting that up in Word is covered in using a reference manager in Word. For work you cite that is not yet published, see citing a manuscript in preparation or under review.
ICMJE asks authors to verify references against a bibliographic source such as PubMed or the original sources, and to make sure none cites a retracted article, except when the reference is about the retraction. A reference manager copies whatever metadata it was given, errors included.
07The anonymised copy for peer review
A journal with double-anonymous peer review (reviewers and authors don't know each other's names) needs two manuscript files: one with the author details and one anonymised. Taylor & Francis's guidance says the anonymised file must drop author names, acknowledgements and grant details, identifying headers or footers and clinical trial numbers, and that hidden identifying data must be removed from the Word file too.
- Save a copy of the finished manuscript and work only on the copy. Removed metadata may not come back with Undo.
- Delete the title page details, the acknowledgements and the funding statement, or move them to the file with author details.
- Write self-citations in the third person: "Smith and Black (2007) have demonstrated", not "We have previously demonstrated (Smith & Black, 2007)" (Taylor & Francis's example). Where that is impossible, Taylor & Francis says to replace the names with
[author(s)]in the text and in the reference list. - Accept or reject every tracked change (Review › Accept › Accept All Changes) and delete the comments.
- WindowsChoose File › Info › Check for Issues › Inspect Document, click Inspect, then Remove All next to Document Properties and Personal Information and next to Comments, Revisions, Versions, and Annotations.
- MacTaylor & Francis gives this path for Word for Mac: Tools › Protect Document, then tick Remove personal information from this file on save. Save the file.
The Document Inspector can't find text that is hidden in other ways, such as white text on a white background (Microsoft Support), so read the anonymised copy once more for names in figure files, file names and headers.
Two versions, a dozen journal rules and a deadline?Send me the manuscript
08From thesis chapter to manuscript
Turning a thesis chapter into a journal manuscript means removing everything that only makes sense inside the thesis: chapter numbers in headings and captions, roman page numbers, section breaks, the table of contents and cross-references to other chapters. In manuscripts I prepare from theses, chapter-numbered captions ("Table 4.2" in an article with three tables) are the fault I meet most often, followed by line numbers that restart at every old section break.
- Captions: choose References › Insert Caption, pick Table in the Label list, click Numbering, untick Include chapter number and click OK. Then click Close, not OK, so Word doesn't insert a new caption. Repeat for the Figure label. Select everything (Ctrl+A) and press F9 so every caption and cross-reference renumbers (Table 4.2 becomes Table 2). Do this before you remove the heading numbers in the next step.
- Headings: remove the outline numbering (4.2, 4.2.1) unless the journal numbers its sections, and keep to its number of heading levels (three in PLOS ONE).
- Page numbers and breaks: delete the roman-numbered front matter and the section breaks between chapters, so page and line numbers run from 1 to the end without restarting.
- Cross-references: search for "Chapter", "Section" and "Appendix" and rewrite each one ("see Chapter 2" becomes "see the Introduction" or a citation).
- Length: a thesis chapter is usually far over a journal's word limit. Cut to the limit before you format; the formatting is the last step.
The thesis rules this undoes are summarised in my thesis formatting checklist, which is useful as a list of what to strip out.
09Common problems and fixes
Many manuscript formatting problems come from section breaks, pasted content and leftover review marks. The fixes below cover the ones that get manuscripts returned to authors before review.
Line numbers restart on each page or section
The numbering was set to restart, or the document has several sections with different settings. Select the whole document with Ctrl+A (Cmd+A on a Mac), then choose Layout › Line Numbers › Continuous.
Line numbers don't appear
Word shows line numbers only in Print Layout view. Choose View › Print Layout. If they still don't appear on one paragraph, it has Suppress for Current Paragraph turned on; click in that paragraph, choose Layout › Line Numbers and click Suppress for Current Paragraph again to turn it off.
Line numbers show only three digits
Microsoft notes that in documents with more than a thousand numbered lines and narrow margins, continuous numbers can lose their first digit. Widen the left margin slightly so the four-digit numbers fit.
Parts of the text are single spaced
Pasted text often keeps its own spacing. Select everything and apply double spacing with Home › Line and Paragraph Spacing › 2.0, then restore any table bodies the journal allows to stay single spaced.
The submission system rejects the file or the figures
Check three things: the Word file isn't locked or password-protected, each figure is a separate file in an accepted format, and no caption text is inside an image file (PLOS ONE forbids that).
Reviewers see tracked changes or comments
Deleted text and comments travel with the file until they are accepted and deleted. Accept or reject all changes, delete the comments, then run the Document Inspector on Windows to confirm none are left.
10Every journal submission guide
This checklist is the hub for my journal submission guides. Each guide below takes one part of the manuscript further, with the official rules and the Word steps.
- Reading journal author guidelines: where each rule hides on a journal's page and what to do when it is unclear.
- Title page for a manuscript: authors, affiliations, the corresponding author and the statements journals ask for.
- Structure of a journal article (IMRaD): what goes in each section, with examples.
- Format for a review paper: how a review differs from original research.
- APA manuscript format: the professional paper for APA-style journals.
- IEEE paper format and Word template: two columns, IEEE references and the template's styles.
- Cover letter for a journal submission: what editors look for, with a template.
- Manuscripts in preparation and under review: how to cite unpublished work.
11Questions people ask
What is standard manuscript format?
For an academic journal, standard manuscript format is a double-spaced, single-column Word file with page numbers and continuous line numbers, as PLOS ONE requires. Fiction publishers use the same name for a different layout, so for a journal always follow the author guidelines.
Do I have to format my manuscript before the first submission?
Only if the journal says so. Elsevier's "Your Paper, Your Way" and Taylor & Francis's format-free submission let you format after acceptance, while journals such as PLOS ONE set the format from the first submission.
What font should a journal manuscript use?
Use the font the journal names; if it names none, any standard font at a standard size is fine. PLOS ONE accepts any standard font except the one called Symbol.
Should figures go in the manuscript file or separately?
It depends on the journal. PLOS ONE wants each figure as a separate file with the captions in the manuscript, while Elsevier's "Your Paper, Your Way" route only asks that figures and their legends are included somewhere in the submission.
Is there a manuscript template for Google Docs?
Publishers' templates are usually for Word or LaTeX, as Taylor & Francis and Frontiers describe. You can still write the manuscript in Google Docs with line numbers and page numbers turned on, then download it as a Word file and check it in Word.
Checked on . The journal rules come from the ICMJE Recommendations (Preparing a Manuscript for Submission), the PLOS ONE submission guidelines, Elsevier's "Your Paper, Your Way" announcement, LaTeX instructions and artwork checklist, Taylor & Francis's pages on formatting and templates and on anonymous peer review, and Frontiers' manuscript preparation page. The Word steps follow Microsoft Support's pages for Word for Microsoft 365 on Windows (line numbers, spacing, page numbers, captions, Document Inspector) and the Mac page-number steps; the Mac route for removing personal information is Taylor & Francis's. The Google Docs steps follow Google Docs Editors Help.
Sources
- Preparing a Manuscript for Submission to a Medical Journal ICMJE
- Submission Guidelines PLOS ONE
- Your Paper, Your Way now available to all journals Elsevier
- LaTeX instructions Elsevier
- Artwork formats checklist and Artwork and media instructions Elsevier
- Formatting and templates Taylor & Francis Author Services
- Anonymous peer review Taylor & Francis Author Services
- Prepare your manuscript Frontiers
- Double-space the lines in a Word document Microsoft Support
- Add or remove line numbers Microsoft Support
- Insert page numbers Microsoft Support
- Show word count Microsoft Support
- Add chapter numbers to captions in Word Microsoft Support
- Accept or reject tracked changes in Word Microsoft Support
- Remove hidden data and personal information by inspecting documents Microsoft Support
- Use line numbers in Google Docs, Use headers, footers, page numbers and footnotes and Create, view, or download a file Google Docs Editors Help