How to read and apply journal guidelines for authors
To apply a journal's guidelines for authors, open the Instructions for Authors (or Submission guidelines) page of the journal itself, not the publisher's general advice, and turn every rule into one line of a checklist: file type, word limit, abstract and keywords, title page, anonymised manuscript, reference style, tables and figures, and declarations. Then set the manuscript up in Word to match each line before you upload.
- Find the journal's own page: on Taylor & Francis Online it is the Instructions for authors tab; on Springer Nature Link it is Submission guidelines. Save a dated copy.
- Check whether the journal accepts a format-free first submission. If it does, you need the content and a consistent reference style, not the house layout.
- Copy every requirement into a checklist: length, abstract, keywords, title page, anonymity, references, tables, figures, declarations, file type.
- Apply each line in Word with styles, then check the word count, line numbers and anonymised copy last.
01Find the right guidelines
Journal author guidelines are the journal's written rules for what a submission must contain and how it must be laid out. Publishers give them different names: Instructions for Authors (Taylor & Francis), Submission guidelines (Springer Nature), Guide for Authors or Author Guidelines elsewhere. Whatever the name, the page that counts is the one for your journal, because rules differ from journal to journal even at one publisher.
The ICMJE Recommendations, which many medical journals follow, keep sending authors back to the journal: tables are to be prepared "according to the specific journal's requirements", and for table symbols authors should "check each journal's instructions for authors for required practice". Taylor & Francis tells authors to select the journal on Taylor & Francis Online and "click on the instructions for authors tab". On Springer Nature Link, each journal has its own Submission guidelines page, for example link.springer.com/journal/10551/submission-guidelines for the Journal of Business Ethics.
- Journal page over publisher page. The publisher's general guide is a default. Where the journal's own instructions say something different, follow the journal.
- Article type matters. Many journals set different limits for research articles, reviews and short communications. Read the section for your type.
- Special issues can add rules. A call for papers may set its own deadline, length or template.
Save the guidelines page as a PDF with the date in the file name on the day you start. Journals revise their instructions, and when a revision arrives months later you can see which rule changed instead of guessing.
02Turn the author guidelines into a submission checklist
Each journal guideline is easiest to apply as a checklist: one line for each rule, with the exact value the journal gives. Reading the page once and "keeping it in mind" is how manuscripts go in with a 300-word abstract for a 250-word limit. Ten items cover almost every journal: length, abstract, keywords, title page, review model (anonymity), text layout, headings, references, tables and figures, and declarations. Note the article type and the file format at the top of the list as well.
The table below lists the ten items, what to look for, and what one real journal asks. The example is the Journal of Business Ethics, a Springer Nature journal in my own field, as its Submission guidelines read on the date this guide was checked.
| Item | What to note | Journal of Business Ethics |
|---|---|---|
| Length | Limit and what it includes | Average about 8,000 to 10,000 words (including references); no longer than 12,000 |
| Abstract | Word range, structured or not | 150 to 250 words (up to 450 for some articles, such as systematic reviews, if the topic needs it) |
| Keywords | How many | 4 to 6 |
| Title page | Separate file or first page; what goes on it | Separate: title, authors, affiliations, corresponding author, acknowledgements, funding, disclosures |
| Review model | Single or double anonymous | Double-blind; authors anonymise the manuscript |
| Text layout | Font, spacing, page and line numbers | Plain font, e.g. 10-point Times Roman; automatic page numbers |
| Headings | Levels and numbering | No more than three levels |
| References | Style and edition | Name and year in the text; APA 7 author rule encouraged; full DOI links |
| Tables, figures | Placement, file types, captions | Table function; figures in the text; "Fig." in bold in captions |
| Declarations | Funding, competing interests, ethics, data | Required; missing declarations mean the submission is returned |
Write the checklist in your own words, but keep the journal's numbers exactly. "About 250 words" in your notes becomes a 270-word abstract; "150 to 250 words" does not. When a value is given as an example ("e.g., 10-point Times Roman"), note it as a suggestion, not a rule.
03Format-free or formatted first submission?
A format-free submission is a first submission that the journal accepts in any consistent layout and citation style, as long as everything needed for review is there. Taylor & Francis says over 850 of its journals accept manuscripts "using any consistent text and citation format". Other journals expect their layout from the first upload, so check which kind yours is before you spend a day on margins.
Format-free does not mean anything goes. For Taylor & Francis journals in the scheme, the manuscript still needs:
- an abstract, the author affiliations, the figures and the references;
- the research funder information and the conflict of interest disclosures and other ethics statements;
- references in one scholarly style used the same way throughout, each with author names, journal or book title, article or chapter title, year, volume and issue where relevant, and page numbers (DOIs recommended);
- one file with text, figures and tables, double-spaced with line numbers.
After acceptance, Taylor & Francis says that "in most cases" it reformats the article to the journal's style, though you may be asked for keywords, editable source files or a formatted reference list. The Journal of Business Ethics, by contrast, sets out text formatting, title page and declaration rules for submission. The policy is per journal, so the journal's own instructions are the only place to confirm it.
The rule: what the journal's instructions require. Where journals vary: whether layout matters at first submission. My advice: even in a format-free journal, use heading styles and Word's caption and table tools from the start. A revision request often asks for the formatted version, and styles make that an hour's work instead of a week's.
04Apply the rules in Word
Applying journal guidelines in Word means changing styles, not individual paragraphs. A paragraph style is a named set of formatting (font, size, spacing, indents) that Word applies in one click; change the style once and every paragraph using it follows. Set the body text through the Normal style and the headings through Heading 1 to 3, then insert page numbers, line numbers and captions with Word's own commands.
- Font and spacing. On the Home tab, right-click Normal in the Styles gallery and choose Modify. Under Formatting, set the font, size and line spacing the journal names, and click OK. To double-space selected paragraphs directly, press WindowsCtrl+2 MacCmd+2.
- Headings. Apply Heading 1, Heading 2 and Heading 3 and modify each to the journal's format. If the journal allows three levels, check that nothing in the manuscript uses Heading 4.
- Page numbers. Choose Insert › Page Number and pick a position. Springer's guidelines ask for "the automatic page numbering function", so never type numbers into the footer.
- Line numbers. Choose Layout › Line Numbers › Continuous. If the document has several sections, select everything first (WindowsCtrl+A MacCmd+A). Line numbers show only in Print Layout view. My guide to line numbers in Word covers restarting them and leaving out single paragraphs.
- Tables and figures. Build tables with Word's table feature, not tabs and spaces (Springer: "Use the table function, not spreadsheets"), and add numbers with References › Insert Caption. Put each table and figure where the journal asks: in the text, at the end, or in separate files.
- Word count. Check the count in the status bar at the bottom of the window. Select a part of the text (the abstract, say) and the status bar shows its count next to the total. Click the count to open the Word Count box. MacFor a selection, you can also choose Tools › Word Count.
Word's own definitions need care here. Microsoft notes that line numbering skips tables, footnotes, endnotes, text boxes, headers and footers by default, and that a table counts as one line. A reviewer citing "line 214" therefore never points into a table, which is expected and not a fault.
Restyling a 9,000-word manuscript to a new journal's rules?I can do it for you
What counts towards the word limit?
What counts towards a journal's word limit is set by each journal, and the definitions differ widely. The ICMJE Recommendations define the text word count as excluding the abstract, acknowledgements, tables, figure legends and references. The Journal of Business Ethics gives its average article length, 8,000 to 10,000 words, "including references", and a ceiling of 12,000 words. Read the sentence after the number before you start cutting.
- Select from the first word of the introduction to the last word of the conclusion and read the status bar: that is the ICMJE-style text count.
- If the journal counts references too, select down to the end of the reference list instead.
- Write both figures in your checklist. Some submission systems ask for the count in a form field.
05Title page and anonymised manuscript
A journal with double-anonymous (double-blind) review needs two documents: a title page with everything that identifies the authors, and an anonymised manuscript with nothing that does. The Journal of Business Ethics asks for a separate title page with the title, author names, affiliations, the corresponding author's contact details, and any acknowledgements, disclosures or funding, and says identifying information must be removed from the manuscript and accompanying files.
Remove what identifies you from the text
- Self-citations. Refer to your own work in the third person (the Journal of Business Ethics example reads "This work builds on and extends that of Morganton [2015]"). Taylor & Francis allows replacing names with
[author(s)]where the first person can't be avoided. - Acknowledgements and grants. Leave them out of the anonymised version and put them on the title page.
- Headers and footers. Taylor & Francis says not to add page headers or footers that would identify you.
Remove what identifies you from the file
Word stores the author's name in the file's properties and in every comment and tracked change. Document Inspector is the Word tool that finds and removes that hidden data. Microsoft warns that removed data can't always be restored, so run it on a copy.
- Save a copy with File › Save As and open the copy.
- Choose File › Info › Check for Issues › Inspect Document.
- Tick Comments, Revisions, Versions, and Annotations and Document Properties and Personal Information, then click Inspect.
- Click Remove All next to each result you want removed, then Close.
- Work on a copy of the file.
- Clear tracked changes: Microsoft's macOS steps give Accept › Accept All Changes (or Reject › Reject All Changes).
- Clear comments: on the Review tab, click the arrow by Delete, then Delete All Comments in Document (Microsoft's page is written for Word 2019 for Mac).
- Taylor & Francis gives this path for Word for Mac: Tools › Protect Document, then "Remove personal information from this file upon save" (the label may read slightly differently in your version). Save the file.
- Microsoft Support does not document this option for current Word for Mac, so open File › Properties after saving and check that your name has gone.
Microsoft says the Headers, Footers, and Watermarks inspector deals with the information in headers and footers. Page numbers sit in the header or footer, so Remove All there takes them too, and a journal that asks for automatic page numbers gets a manuscript without any. If a header holds your name, delete the name by hand instead.
What goes on a title page, and in what order, depends on the journal and the style: the manuscript title page guide sets out the common versions, and a cover letter for journal submission is often the place to request anonymous review where it is optional.
06APA author guidelines: what "APA Style" means
When a journal's author guidelines say "APA Style", check which part of APA they mean. The APA Publication Manual (7th edition) covers the whole paper: page layout, title page, headings, tables, figures, citations and references. Some journals use APA only for citations and references and set their own layout. The Journal of Business Ethics, for example, asks for name-and-year citations and encourages the APA 7 rule on authors in reference entries, yet suggests 10-point Times Roman and a separate title page with acknowledgements.
A journal that wants the full APA professional paper format expects the layout of APA's sample professional paper. In that sample, the title page has a running head in capitals and the page number at the top, the bold title, the authors and their affiliations, and a bold Author Note; the abstract follows on its own page, with an indented, italic Keywords: label below it. The details are in my guide to APA professional manuscript format.
- "References in APA style" means the reference list and in-text citations follow APA 7; the layout follows the journal.
- "Prepare the manuscript according to the APA Publication Manual" means the full professional paper format, including title page, running head and heading levels.
- No edition given? My advice: use the 7th edition unless the journal says otherwise, and say so in the cover letter if you are unsure.
Other journals follow other systems. Engineering and computing journals often use IEEE, with a two-column template; the IEEE paper format guide explains that template.
07From thesis chapter to journal article
Turning a thesis chapter into a journal article means rewriting a document built for examiners into one built for a journal's guidelines. A thesis chapter carries chapter numbering, cross-references to other chapters, chapter-based table numbers and a reference list for the whole thesis. A journal wants a stand-alone article inside a word limit, with its own reference list of works cited in that article only, which is what the Journal of Business Ethics asks for.
Take the results chapter of the fictional thesis "Brand trust and customer loyalty in subscription services", with its survey of 412 subscribers. In the article version:
- Headings: "4.2 Brand trust and loyalty" becomes "Brand Trust and Loyalty" at the level the journal uses, unnumbered unless the journal numbers headings.
- Tables and figures: Table 4.2 becomes Table 2. In Word's caption Numbering settings, untick Include chapter number, then update all fields.
- Cross-references: "as discussed in Section 2.1" points to a chapter the reader doesn't have. Rewrite it to summarise the point or cite the source.
- Wording: "this thesis" and "this chapter" become "this article" or "this study".
- References: keep only the works the article cites.
Reference managers need one extra decision. Springer's text formatting list for the Journal of Business Ethics includes "Do not use field functions", and citations inserted by a reference manager are fields. Zotero's Unlink Citations button converts them to plain text, but its documentation calls this irreversible, so do it only in a copy made for submission. To unlink every field in the body of a copy at once, select all and press WindowsCtrl+Shift+F9 MacCmd+Shift+F9 (add Fn if your F keys control brightness and volume). Page numbers in the footer are not affected, because selecting all in the body does not reach the headers and footers.
The step authors skip most is the reference list. A chapter cut from a thesis keeps entries the article no longer cites. With a reference manager still linked, the list rebuilds itself from the citations left in the text; after unlinking, check every entry against the text by hand.
Turning a thesis chapter into a submission-ready article?I can set it to the journal's rules
The complete layout of a journal manuscript, from the first page to the files you upload, is in my guide to formatting a journal manuscript for submission.
08When the guidelines are unclear or contradict themselves
Journal guidelines often combine a publisher template with journal-specific rules, and the two can disagree on the same page. When a journal guideline contradicts itself, follow the more specific rule, note the conflict, and ask the editorial office if it affects what reviewers see. These are the problems I meet most often.
Two rules on one page seem to say different things
The Journal of Business Ethics guidelines, read for this guide, ask for funding, competing interests and other statements "under the heading 'Statements and Declarations'" for the published paper, and further down say "Please use the title page for providing the statements". Read on and the page resolves it: the statements go on the title page at submission, and "once and if the paper is accepted", Springer's production department moves them into a separate section. The lesson: read the sentence after a rule before treating two rules as a conflict.
"Do not use field functions", but "use automatic page numbering"
Automatic page numbers are themselves a field in Word, so read the two rules together: keep the page numbers, and convert citation, caption-number and cross-reference fields to plain text in the submission copy, as in section 07 (page numbers sit in the footer, so selecting all in the body leaves them alone).
The template and the written instructions differ
Taylor & Francis notes that each template comes with its own instructions file and that some journals have specific layout requirements. When the downloaded template and the journal's current page disagree, the current page is newer. Use the template for its styles and the page for the values.
The manuscript was sent back for formatting
A return before review is usually a missing item, not bad prose: no line numbers, author names left in the manuscript, an abstract over the limit or missing declarations. The Journal of Business Ethics says submissions without the relevant declarations are returned as incomplete. Go back to your checklist, fix every line, and say in the resubmission what you changed.
The guidelines don't mention something
When the guidelines are silent, the publisher's general guide is the fallback. Taylor & Francis's manuscript layout guide, for example, suggests five or six keywords when the journal sets no number, Times New Roman 12 point with double spacing, and margins of at least 2.5 cm (1 inch).
Desk-returned for formatting and short of time?Send it to me and I'll work through the guidelines
09Questions people ask
Where do I find a journal's author guidelines?
A journal's author guidelines are on the journal's own page at its publisher: the Instructions for authors tab on Taylor & Francis Online, or the Submission guidelines page on Springer Nature Link. Search the journal's name with "instructions for authors" or "submission guidelines" if you can't see the link.
Do I have to format my manuscript before the first submission?
Only if the journal asks for it. Over 850 Taylor & Francis journals accept a format-free first submission in any consistent style, while journals such as the Journal of Business Ethics set formatting rules for submission. The journal's instructions say which applies.
How many keywords should I give?
Give the number the journal's guidelines set, such as 4 to 6 for the Journal of Business Ethics. If the guidelines give no number, Taylor & Francis suggests five or six.
Does the word limit include references?
It depends on the journal. The ICMJE Recommendations exclude the abstract, acknowledgements, tables, figure legends and references from the text count, while the Journal of Business Ethics gives its average length of 8,000 to 10,000 words including references.
What is the difference between author guidelines and a journal template?
Author guidelines are the journal's written rules; a journal template is a Word or LaTeX file with styles already set to those rules. Not every journal has a template, and Taylor & Francis notes that a template may not be needed at all.
Updated . Journal rules come from the pages listed under Sources: the Journal of Business Ethics Submission guidelines (Springer Nature), Taylor & Francis Author Services, the ICMJE Recommendations and APA's sample professional paper from the Publication Manual (7th edition). Word steps come from Microsoft Support for Word for Microsoft 365; the Word for Mac privacy path is the one Taylor & Francis publishes, as Microsoft does not document it for current Word for Mac. Journals revise their guidelines, so the journal's current page always wins over this guide.
Sources
- Submission guidelines: Journal of Business Ethics Springer Nature Link
- Preparing a Manuscript for Submission to a Medical Journal ICMJE
- Save time with format-free manuscript submission Taylor & Francis Author Services
- Formatting and using a journal template Taylor & Francis Author Services
- Taylor & Francis manuscript layout guide Taylor & Francis Author Services
- Anonymous peer review Taylor & Francis Author Services
- Annotated sample professional paper (PDF) APA Style
- Remove hidden data and personal information by inspecting documents, presentations, or workbooks Microsoft Support
- Customize or create new styles Microsoft Support
- Insert page numbers Microsoft Support
- Add chapter numbers to captions in Word Microsoft Support
- Add or remove line numbers Microsoft Support
- Show word count Microsoft Support
- Keyboard shortcuts in Word Microsoft Support
- Track changes in Word Microsoft Support
- Insert, delete, or change a comment Microsoft Support
- Using the Zotero Word Plugin Zotero Documentation